Which Decking Material is Right for Me? Let's Compare!

Choosing the right material is one of the most important decisions you’ll make when planning a new deck space. The material you select affects not only the tone of your outdoor space, but also its longevity, maintenance requirements, and overall cost of ownership.

There is no universal “best” decking material. Each option comes with distinct advantages and limitations. This comparison breaks down the most common decking materials—so you can choose the one that best aligns with your lifestyle, budget, and long-term expectations.

Pressure-Treated Wood

Price Gauge: $ (Most Affordable)

Pressure-treated wood remains one of the most commonly used decking materials due to its low upfront cost and wide availability. It is chemically treated to resist rot and insects, making it structurally sound for outdoor use.

However, pressure-treated decks require consistent maintenance. Annual or biannual staining and sealing are necessary to protect against moisture intrusion, warping, cracking, and splintering. Over time, boards can become uneven or visually worn if maintenance is deferred.

Best suited for: Homeowners prioritizing initial affordability and who are comfortable with ongoing maintenance.

Cedar and Redwood

Price Gauge: $$ (Moderate)

Cedar and redwood are natural wood options known for their rich color and classic appearance. These woods are naturally resistant to insects and decay without chemical treatment, which appeals to homeowners seeking a more organic material.

While they offer improved aesthetics over pressure-treated lumber, they still require routine sealing or staining to preserve color and prevent weathering. Without maintenance, these woods will fade to a silvery gray and may experience surface wear.

Best suited for: Homeowners who value natural beauty and are willing to invest time in ongoing upkeep.

Composite Decking (Wood-Plastic Blends)

Price Gauge: $$$ (Premium)

Composite decking blends wood fibers with recycled plastics to create a durable, low-maintenance alternative to traditional wood. It resists rot, insects, splintering, and most moisture-related issues.

The primary tradeoff is cost. Composite materials carry a higher upfront price and are heavier than wood, sometimes requiring more robust framing. Many options are equipped with a poly coating to resist surface temperature changes and color fading .

That said, composite decking typically lasts decades with minimal maintenance, making it a popular long-term investment.

Best suited for: Homeowners seeking durability, consistency, and minimal maintenance over time.

PVC (100% Synthetic) Decking

Price Gauge: $$$$ (Highest)

PVC decking is entirely synthetic and offers the highest level of moisture resistance among decking materials. It does not absorb water, rot, warp, or support mold growth—making it ideal for pool decks or areas with heavy moisture exposure.

While PVC requires very little maintenance, it tends to have a more uniform, less natural appearance than wood or composite options. It also carries the highest price point and must be installed with proper allowances for expansion and contraction.

Best suited for: High-moisture environments and homeowners who want the lowest possible maintenance.

Exotic Hardwood Decking (Ipe, Cumaru, Tigerwood)

Price Gauge: $$$$ (Highest)

Exotic hardwoods are prized for their dense structure, natural resistance to rot and insects, and striking visual appeal. When properly installed and maintained, these materials can last 30 years or more.

Their density makes them more difficult and costly to install, and periodic oiling is required to maintain their rich color. Without oiling, they weather to a gray patina similar to other natural woods.

Best suited for: Luxurious projects where longevity and high-end aesthetics are the primary priorities.

Comparing Cost vs. Long-Term Value

While upfront cost is an important factor, it should not be the only one. Lower-cost materials often require more frequent maintenance and repairs, while premium materials typically offer longer lifespans and reduced upkeep.

In many cases, homeowners find that investing more initially results in fewer long-term headaches, lower maintenance costs, and greater enjoyment of the space.

When it comes to building your deck planning carefully and with intention is a must. It’s an extension of your home and lifestyle. The right decking material balances aesthetics, durability, maintenance expectations, and long-term value.

Before making a final decision, it’s wise to consult with a professional who understands how each material performs in real-world conditions, especially in climates with strong sun exposure, temperature swings, and seasonal moisture. An informed choice today leads to a deck you’ll enjoy for decades—not just the first season.

Composite Decking by Trex